Shelter Island beach bungalow — front exterior with green lawn and flowering tree

Shelter Island Bungalow

46 N Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

2 Bedroom w/ loft

1 Bath

1/2 Acre

1 mi to Beach

Living Spaces

Open living room with vaulted ceiling, TV area, and decorative oars

Sunny living room with white furniture and large window overlooking the yard

Living room with grey shiplap walls, coastal pillows, and jute rug

Open floor plan showing loft ladder, bookshelves, and dining area

Bedrooms

Master bedroom with king bed, beach art, and sliding doors to deck

Master bedroom view toward sliding glass doors opening to the deck and yard

Loft sleeping area with two double beds in a cozy A-frame space

Second bedroom with twin bunk beds and blue striped bedding

View up to the vaulted loft with white railings and ladder access

Kitchen & Bath

Renovated galley kitchen with white cabinets, hex tile floor, and black hardware

Kitchen with induction stove, microwave, and glass tile backsplash

Bathroom with white subway tile, glass shower door, and modern vanity

Laundry room with new washer and dryer, cabinets, and glass tile backsplash

Outdoors

Full-length back deck with lounge chairs and dining area overlooking green lawn

Secluded fire pit area with Adirondack chairs on gravel

Fenced half-acre yard with mature trees and garden shed

Book Your Stay

Airbnb Corcoran

airbnb.com/h/si-bungalow

Planning a longer stay? Reach out directly for discounted pricing.

shelterislandbungalow@gmail.com

About This Property

A bright, open contemporary perfect for a beach vacation or quiet weekend escape. The sunny living room opens to a big master bedroom with sliding doors to the back deck, a second bedroom with twin bunk beds, and a loft with two double beds — sleeping up to six guests comfortably.

The recently renovated kitchen features modern appliances, and the laundry room has a brand new washer and dryer. Outside, the landscaped and fully fenced half-acre yard has a full-length deck, an outdoor shower, green lawns, and a secluded fire pit area — ideal for summer evenings after a day at the beach.

Features

—Recently renovated kitchen
—Brand new washer & dryer
—Full-length back deck
—Outdoor shower
—Fully fenced yard
—Secluded fire pit area
—Central A/C
—1 mile from Crescent Beach
—Near Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island

Tucked between the North and South Forks of Long Island, Shelter Island is a peaceful escape from New York City — reachable by a short ferry ride from Greenport or Sag Harbor. There are no traffic lights, no chain stores, and no crowds. Just quiet roads, nature preserves, and miles of coastline.

Crescent Beach is a one-mile walk from the house — a calm, shallow stretch perfect for families and swimming. Shelter Island Heights is just as close, with restaurants, an ice cream shop, a pharmacy, and the South Ferry dock. The Mashomack Preserve offers over 2,000 acres of trails and wildlife for hiking and kayaking.

The island has a growing food scene with farm-to-table dining at spots like The Dory and Vine Street Cafe. Greenport and Sag Harbor — both a quick ferry hop away — add wine bars, bookshops, and more restaurants to the mix. It's the Hamptons without the Hamptons.

Whether you're looking for a week-long beach vacation with family, a quiet long weekend away, or a seasonal rental for the summer, this bungalow puts you in the center of everything Shelter Island has to offer — with the privacy of a fenced half-acre property to come home to.